The media is a bit obsessed with debating who the leader of the Republican Party is. But as I noted on MSNBC earlier this week, the party benefits from lots of strong leaders – especially our Republican governors like Pawlenty and Jindal.
In some ways, our situation is not dissimilar from the Democratic Party in 2001, an observation made my none other than David Axelrod at the time. From an August 2001 USA Today story:
Asked who is the leader of the Democratic Party, a 51% majority in a new USA TODAY/CNN/Gallup Poll didn’t have an opinion. The next most frequent answer, at 10%: No one. …. “It’s the nature of being the party out of power,” says David Axelrod, a Democratic consultant based in Chicago.
At the same time, Chris Cillizza’s morning post compares three Republican leaders — Newt Gingrich, Sarah Palin and Tim Pawlenty — in a smart and thought-provoking analysis:
The triptych of appearances illustrated the three parts of the GOP “body” politic: the heart (Palin), the head (Gingrich) and the gut (Pawlenty).
The Heart: Palin’s appeal within the GOP is derived from the sense that she “gets” the hopes, dreams and worries of the average Republican footsoldier. …
The Head: Gingrich is clearly one of the leading thinkers within the Republican Party, a man deeply versed in political theory, history and any number of other areas. …
The Gut: Pawlenty, as we have written before, is the leading populist in the party at the moment. … Pawlenty’s personal story — first in his family to go to college, a truck driver father etc. — is at the heart of his appeal in Minnesota, a state not particularly inclined to support Republicans in statewide elections.


